Saggi e contributi scientifici

Nuovi istituti deflattivi del contenzioso nel Codice del processo contabile


Abstract


This article examines the introduction of new dispute-settling (deflative) mechanisms in the Italian Code of Accounting Justice, as envisaged by Article 3 of Law No. 1/2026. The legislative delegation aims both to improve the efficiency of the Court of Auditors and to address perceived inequities in administrative liability proceedings, particularly through mechanisms allowing early resolution of disputes.

The core innovation analysed is a pre-trial settlement procedure enabling the alleged liable party (“incolpato”) to request the definition of their position by offering a lump-sum payment corresponding to a percentage of the amount indicated in the invitation to respond, prior to formal litigation. This mechanism is initiated exclusively by the accused and is subject to evaluation by the public prosecutor and final decision by the judge.

The article highlights both the defined elements of the reform—such as timing, procedural structure, and payment conditions—and the significant uncertainties, including the binding nature of the prosecutor’s assessment and the procedural path for judicial involvement. It argues that these mechanisms must be coherently integrated into the existing system, alongside current tools such as the abbreviated procedure and the monitoring procedure.

A central thesis is that such deflative instruments are less relevant to improving formal efficiency than to enhancing the effectiveness of administrative justice. Given the chronic difficulty in enforcing judgments for damages to the public treasury, early settlement mechanisms may ensure more immediate and certain recovery of public funds.


Full Text

PDF

Riferimenti bibliografici





I contenuti redazionali di questo sito sono distribuiti con una licenza Creative Commons, Attribuzione - Condividi allo stesso modo 3.0 Italia (CC BY-SA 3.0 IT) eccetto dove diversamente specificato. Diretta da G. Terracciano, G. Mazzei, J. Espartero Casado. Direttore Responsabile: G. Caputi. Redazione: C. Rizzo. Iscritta al N. 16/2009 del Reg. stampa del Tribunale di Roma - ISSN 2036-7821